Question
For a reaction, kJ/mol and J/K/mol at 298 K. Calculate and predict whether the reaction is spontaneous at this temperature.
Solution — Step by Step
The Gibbs-Helmholtz equation relates , , and :
This equation tells us that spontaneity depends on the balance between enthalpy (energy released) and entropy (disorder change) at a given temperature.
kJ/mol = J/mol
J/K/mol (already in J, not kJ)
K
We must convert to J (or to kJ) before substituting — mixing kJ and J is the most common mistake in this type of problem.
Since (negative), the reaction is spontaneous at 298 K under standard conditions.
Why This Works
The sign of tells us the direction of spontaneous change at constant temperature and pressure:
- : spontaneous (forward reaction favoured)
- : non-spontaneous (reverse reaction favoured)
- : system at equilibrium
In this problem, both (negative = exothermic, favours spontaneity) and (negative = decrease in disorder, opposes spontaneity) work against each other. The enthalpy effect wins at 298 K, making negative.
At higher temperatures, the term grows larger, and eventually will become positive — the reaction becomes non-spontaneous above a crossover temperature .
Above 465 K, this reaction is non-spontaneous.
Alternative Method — Finding Crossover Temperature
If asked “at what temperature does the reaction stop being spontaneous?”:
Set :
The reaction is spontaneous for K.
Common Mistake
Unit mismatch is the #1 error here. Students write , forgetting to convert from kJ to J. They get kJ — wildly wrong. Always check: if is in kJ, convert to kJ/K (divide by 1000), or convert to J (multiply by 1000). Never mix units.
In JEE Main, this type of problem often adds “find the temperature at which equilibrium is attained” — that means find where , i.e., . This appeared in JEE Main 2022 Session 2.