Question
Explain the diagonal relationship between lithium (Li) and magnesium (Mg) with examples.
Solution — Step by Step
In the periodic table, elements show a diagonal relationship when an element in one group resembles the element diagonally placed in the next period and next group more closely than it resembles the elements directly below it in its own group.
The three classic diagonal pairs:
- Li (Group 1, Period 2) ↔ Mg (Group 2, Period 3)
- Be (Group 2, Period 2) ↔ Al (Group 13, Period 3)
- B (Group 13, Period 2) ↔ Si (Group 14, Period 3)
The diagonal relationship arises from a similarity in ionic charge density (charge/size ratio) of the diagonally placed elements. As we move across a period, atomic size decreases (nuclear charge increases). As we move down a group, atomic size increases. These two trends partially cancel each other along a diagonal, resulting in similar charge densities.
Li radius ≈ 76 pm. Mg radius ≈ 72 pm. Both have high charge-to-radius ratios (charge density) — Li with charge 1 and Mg with charge 2 but larger radius effectively have comparable polarising power.
1. Behaviour with oxygen: Both Li and Mg form normal oxides when burned in air. Na (just below Li in Group 1) forms sodium peroxide (), but:
- Li burns in to form (normal oxide)
- Mg burns in to form (normal oxide)
2. Nitride formation: Both react directly with nitrogen to form nitrides. Na and K do NOT do this readily.
- (lithium nitride)
- (magnesium nitride)
3. Carbonate stability: Both and decompose on heating to form oxides. Higher alkali metal carbonates (, ) are stable to heat.
4. Bicarbonate: is unstable and exists only in solution. Same for . Higher alkali metal bicarbonates are solid.
5. Solubility of fluorides and hydroxides: and are sparingly soluble, unlike (very soluble). and are sparingly soluble; is very soluble.
6. Organometallic compounds: Both form organometallic compounds readily. Grignard reagents () are analogous to organolithium compounds (). Higher alkali metals (Na, K) don’t form stable organometallics of the same type.
Why This Works
The similar charge density of Li and Mg means they polarise anions to a similar extent and have similar hydration energies. This causes their salts to have similar solubility trends, their hydroxides to be similarly basic (weakly so), and their oxides to behave similarly. Group 1 elements below Li (Na, K, Rb, Cs) have much lower charge density (larger ions with charge +1), making them behave very differently.
Common Mistake
Students often say “Li is more similar to Na than to Mg.” In terms of group membership, yes — but in terms of chemical behaviour (oxide type, nitride formation, carbonate stability, solubility), Li is actually more similar to Mg. This is the entire point of the diagonal relationship. The diagonal relationship is an exception to the periodic trend within a group — it arises from charge density matching rather than group membership.