Question
What is lanthanoid contraction? Explain its cause and describe its consequences on the properties of 5d transition series elements.
(JEE Main 2022, similar pattern)
Solution — Step by Step
Lanthanoid contraction is the steady decrease in atomic and ionic radii of the 14 lanthanoid elements (Ce to Lu) as we move across the series from left to right. The decrease is small but cumulative — by the end of the series, the size has shrunk significantly.
For example, the ionic radius of is 106 pm, while is 85 pm — a drop of about 21 pm across 14 elements.
As we move from Ce to Lu, electrons are added to the 4f subshell. The 4f orbitals have a diffuse, complex shape and poor spatial penetration toward the nucleus. This means 4f electrons do a poor job of shielding the outer electrons from the increasing nuclear charge.
With each added proton (nuclear charge increases by +1) and each added 4f electron (which barely shields), the effective nuclear charge felt by the outer electrons increases. This pulls the electron cloud inward, shrinking the atomic radius.
The cumulative effect of lanthanoid contraction profoundly affects the 5d series (Hf to Hg):
- Similar radii of 4d and 5d elements: Zr and Hf have nearly identical atomic radii (160 pm vs 159 pm). Without lanthanoid contraction, Hf would be much larger.
- Separation difficulty: Zr-Hf and Nb-Ta pairs are extremely difficult to separate chemically because their similar sizes give them almost identical chemical properties.
- Higher densities and melting points: 5d elements are denser and have higher melting points than expected because of the smaller-than-predicted atomic size.
- Higher ionisation energies: The 5d elements have unexpectedly high ionisation energies compared to what periodic trends alone would predict.
Why This Works
Normally, when we go down a group in the periodic table, atomic radius increases because new electron shells are added. But lanthanoid contraction partly cancels this increase for the 5d elements. The 14 lanthanoids inserted between the 5d elements cause such a cumulative size reduction that 5d elements end up nearly the same size as their 4d counterparts.
Think of it this way: the 5d elements “should” be bigger (new shell added), but the lanthanoid contraction “claws back” most of that size increase.
JEE Main frequently asks: “Why are Zr and Hf almost identical in size?” or “Why is it difficult to separate Zr from Hf?” The answer is always lanthanoid contraction. This is a 2-3 mark guaranteed question — learn the cause (poor 4f shielding) and at least three consequences.
Alternative Method
You can also explain lanthanoid contraction using Slater’s rules. The shielding constant for 4f electrons is very low (approximately 0.85 per 4f electron against outer electrons, compared to ~1.0 for inner shell electrons). This means effective nuclear charge keeps increasing across the lanthanoid series, causing contraction.
Common Mistake
Students often write that lanthanoid contraction is caused by “poor shielding by d-electrons.” This is wrong — the contraction across the lanthanoid series is caused by poor shielding of 4f electrons, not d-electrons. The d-block contraction (across the 3d series) is a separate phenomenon with a similar mechanism but involving 3d electrons.
Also, do not confuse lanthanoid contraction with the general decrease in size across any period. Lanthanoid contraction is specifically the cumulative effect of filling the 4f subshell, and its significance lies in how it affects the subsequent 5d series.