Question
The system is at equilibrium. What happens when we add more to the system at constant temperature and volume?
Solution — Step by Step
Adding increases its concentration. The system was balanced — now the forward reaction side suddenly has more reactant than the equilibrium demands.
Le Chatelier’s Principle says: the system will shift in the direction that reduces the disturbance. Since we’ve added (a reactant), the system shifts right — toward products — to consume the extra .
As the reaction shifts forward:
- decreases (being consumed), but not back to its original value
- decreases (also being consumed)
- increases (being produced)
The reaction shifts until a new equilibrium is reached. The value of doesn’t change — temperature hasn’t changed. But the equilibrium concentrations of all species are now different from before.
The equilibrium shifts to the right. More is produced. The system reaches a new equilibrium position at which once again.
Final Answer: Adding shifts the equilibrium to the right, producing more .
Why This Works
When we add , the reaction quotient temporarily becomes less than . The system isn’t at equilibrium anymore — the numerator of the equilibrium expression () is too small relative to the denominator ().
To restore balance, the forward reaction runs faster than the reverse until climbs back up to . This is exactly what “shifting right” means — it’s not a vague statement, it’s the system adjusting rates to re-establish the equilibrium ratio.
The key insight: Le Chatelier is just a shortcut for the vs logic. If you ever get confused, just calculate what adding a reactant does to — it always drops below , so the forward reaction dominates.
Alternative Method — Using vs
Instead of stating Le Chatelier’s principle directly, we can reason through :
At the original equilibrium, . The moment we add , the denominator increases. So now:
Since , the reaction proceeds forward to produce more and reduce and , until again.
This method is more reliable on tricky questions where Le Chatelier’s “direction” isn’t immediately obvious (e.g., adding an inert gas, or changing volume with unequal moles).
In JEE/NEET MCQs, when they ask “what happens to equilibrium when X is added”, the fastest approach is: check whether X is a reactant or product, then apply vs logic. For here — it’s a reactant, so , so the reaction goes forward. Three seconds.
Common Mistake
Students often write: “Adding shifts equilibrium right, so returns to its original value.”
This is wrong. After the shift, is higher than the original equilibrium value — just not as high as the value immediately after addition. The system partially consumes the added , but cannot fully undo the change (that would violate conservation). This is a classic NCERT-based board exam trap — CBSE Class 11 papers have asked this exact follow-up.