Question
A pendulum clock gains 5 minutes per day. How should the length of the pendulum be changed to make the clock keep correct time?
Solution — Step by Step
A clock gains time means it runs fast — it completes more oscillations per day than required. If it gains 5 minutes in one day (86400 seconds), it ticks through 86400 seconds of time in only actual seconds.
The clock’s period is slightly less than the correct period seconds (for a seconds pendulum). Since the clock is fast, it is completing cycles too quickly — the period is too short.
The time period of a simple pendulum is:
This shows . If we want to increase the period (slow the clock down), we need to increase the length.
This is the physical intuition: a longer pendulum swings more slowly, taking more time per oscillation, so the clock runs more slowly.
Let = correct period, = current (too short) period.
The clock gains 5 minutes in 24 hours = 86400 seconds. This means in seconds (one correct day), the clock shows 86400 + 300 = 86700 seconds.
So the ratio:
Wait — let’s think carefully. The clock completes oscillations in one day (86400 actual seconds). For correct time, it should complete oscillations.
The actual ratio:
Since the clock gains, it does more oscillations → shorter period → ✓
Using :
We need the new length such that :
The length should be increased by approximately 0.69% of its current length.
To slow the clock down (from gaining to correct):
- Increase the length of the pendulum by about 0.69% of its current length.
In a typical grandfather clock, this is done by lowering the bob (the heavy weight at the bottom of the pendulum) using an adjusting screw.
Why This Works
The period of a pendulum scales as — a longer pendulum means a longer period, meaning the clock ticks more slowly. Raising the bob shortens the effective length (faster clock); lowering the bob increases the effective length (slower clock).
The approximation for small is valid here since is small compared to 1.
Alternative Method
Use the fractional error approach. If the clock gains seconds per day in total seconds:
Since :
Increase length by . Same answer.
Common Mistake
Students often conclude “decrease the length” because “the clock is going fast and more length means more distance to cover” — this reasoning is wrong. A longer pendulum does travel farther per swing, but it swings more slowly because it needs more time to travel that arc. The period formula shows clearly that increasing increases (slows the pendulum). Always trust the formula over intuition for this type of problem.