Question
State Mendel’s Law of Independent Assortment. Illustrate it with a dihybrid cross between two pea plants, showing the expected phenotypic ratio in the F₂ generation.
Solution — Step by Step
Mendel’s Law of Independent Assortment (Second Law): The alleles of two different genes are distributed independently of each other into gametes during the formation of gametes (meiosis).
In other words, the segregation of one gene pair does not influence the segregation of another gene pair — provided the genes are on different (non-homologous) chromosomes.
This law explains why the two traits in a dihybrid cross behave as if they were two separate monohybrid crosses happening simultaneously.
Consider Mendel’s classic cross for seed colour and seed shape in peas:
- Seed colour: Yellow (Y) dominant over Green (y)
- Seed shape: Round (R) dominant over Wrinkled (r)
Parental cross (P generation):
- Pure yellow round: YYRR
- Pure green wrinkled: yyrr
F₁ generation: All YyRr (yellow round — both dominant traits expressed)
F₁ plants are all yellow and round, confirming dominance.
When F₁ plants (YyRr) form gametes, the Y/y pair segregates independently of the R/r pair.
Possible gametes from YyRr:
- YR, Yr, yR, yr (4 types, each with probability 1/4)
F₂ Punnett square (4×4):
| YR | Yr | yR | yr | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| YR | YYRR | YYRr | YyRR | YyRr |
| Yr | YYRr | YYrr | YyRr | Yyrr |
| yR | YyRR | YyRr | yyRR | yyRr |
| yr | YyRr | Yyrr | yyRr | yyrr |
From the 16 combinations:
| Phenotype | Genotypes | Count |
|---|---|---|
| Yellow Round | Y_R_ | 9 |
| Yellow Wrinkled | Y_rr | 3 |
| Green Round | yyR_ | 3 |
| Green Wrinkled | yyrr | 1 |
F₂ Phenotypic ratio = 9:3:3:1
This 9:3:3:1 ratio is the hallmark of independent assortment in a dihybrid cross.
Why This Works
The 9:3:3:1 ratio is exactly what you get if the two monohybrid ratios (3:1 for each trait) are multiplied independently:
This mathematical equivalence is proof that the two traits segregate independently. If they were linked (on the same chromosome), the ratio would deviate from 9:3:3:1.
Independent assortment occurs because homologous chromosomes line up independently at the metaphase plate during meiosis I. The orientation of one pair has no influence on the orientation of another pair.
Alternative Method — Forked Line Method
Instead of a 4×4 Punnett square, use the forked-line (branch) method:
Color alone (Yy × Yy): 3 Yellow : 1 Green
For each colour outcome, apply the shape ratio (Rr × Rr): 3 Round : 1 Wrinkled
Yellow branch: YR; Yr
Green branch: yR; yr
Result: 9:3:3:1 — same answer, faster method.
Common Mistake
Saying the law applies to ALL genes. Mendel’s Law of Independent Assortment applies only to genes located on DIFFERENT chromosomes (non-homologous). Genes on the same chromosome tend to be inherited together (linked) and do NOT show independent assortment. This linkage was discovered after Mendel — it is the major exception to his second law.